Performing WITH a local band, while trying to keep my on-stage sound as close to a local band sound as possible, I also try to play in the style of a typical local band.
This would only seem reasonable to someone who has played with various local bands over a long period and understands what that experience is like.
Typically, a local band is 3, 4, or (at one point 7 or 8) other musicians, all of whom are at different stages of development or experience.
When I started my first professional local band, we were four teenagers with little or no experience. In fact our drummer had never played drums (but he could afford to buy a drum set). So he was a natural.
Basically, anyone playing as a local musician is usually exempt from public criticism for most mistakes. In fact, I know from experience that most people never notice an error unless the tempo varies so much that they have to stop dancing.
So, as a local musician, don’t worry if your sound doesn’t meet recording quality. No one expects it.